Global Warming - Drought & Chinese Imports Shape an "Experiment in Agriculture" for Colorado

"...THOSE WHO LABOR IN THE EARTH ARE THETHEY ARE TIED TO THEIR COUNTRY, AND
CHOSEN PEOPLE OF GOD, IF HE EVER HAD AWEDDED TO ITS LIBERTY AND INTEREST, BUY
CHOSEN PEOPLE, WHOSE BREASTS HE HAS MADETHE MOST LASTING BONDS. AS LONG AS THEY
THE PECULIAR DEPOSITS FOR SUBSTANTIAL ANDCAN FIND EMPLOYMENT IN THIS LINE, I WOULD
GENUINE VIRTUE. IT IS THE FOCUS IN WHICH HENOT CONVERT THEM INTO MARINERS, ARTISANS,
KEEPS ALIVE THAT SACRED FIRE WHICHOR ANYTHING ELSE..." Thomas Jefferson, 1785
OTHERWISE MIGHT NOT ESCAPE FROM THEIntroduction to the Piñon
EARTH". Thomas Jefferson, 1789Of approximately (14) species of cultivated nuts in
Ethno-Agriculturethe United States, the Piñon remains to come
According to the book "The History of Agriculture inunder cultivation.
Colorado" the primitive plows used to break the soil inThe ancestor of the piñon pine was a member
Colorado's first agricultural settlements (San Luisof the Madro-Tertiary Flora, (a group of drought
Valley) were made of piñon wood for itsresistant species), which starting 60 million years ago,
superior strength. The Piñon was life to ourits host climate started to change from moist to dry.
agricultural communities, and more than a few earlyPiñon (Pinus Edulis) grows slowly into a small,
exploration parties in the Rockies, both Spanish anddrought hardy, and quite long lived native species of
American, were saved from starvation by Pinyon andthe Southwestern United States. It common name is
its nuts. The Piñon Pine, the Piñon Nutderived from the Spanish piñon and refers to
and the settlement of humans in Colorado have athe large seed of the pino (pine). Other common
history that traces back to the Basketmaker Culturenames are Colorado Piñon, and nut pine.
under the Pecos Classification System. PiñonExisting woodlands, where Piñon is the major
ecosystems have had subsistence, cultural, spiritual,species, cover about 36 million acres combined in
economic, aesthetic and medicinal value to NativeColorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Arizona, but
American peoples for centuries and continue to bedrought and resulting pine beetle attacks and various
widely studied in its past & present zone(s).pathogens have had considerable effect on
Among ethno-botanists and archeologists, aPiñon stands.
consensus is that the first human settlements inPiñon trees develop in areas with annual
Colorado resulted from the Piñon Nut providingprecipitation from a low of 10" annually, to upwards
a winter protein source - sustaining life when gameof 22" inches, and where temperatures exist from an
animals were scarce - allowing man to build the firstextreme low of -35 Celsius, all within as short as 90
societies (Cliff Dwellings) in Colorado.days of frost-free annually. In its highest elevation
Agriculture in the East beats Western Agriculturerange and northern most latitude, native Piñon
Currently, over 80% of the $49 million dollars in Pinegrowth can be found in a variety of soil depths,
Nuts consumed in the U.S. market are IMPORTEDtextures, from rocky gravels, to fine, compacted
FROM CHINA, with no benefit to westernclays, and at elevations from 4500 to 7500 foot
landowners. "We have thousands of US householdselevations, with isolated specimens up to 9400 feet.
who buy & eat Pine Nuts - unaware of theirFrom research into the most desirable Piñon
true Chinese origin". Pine Nuts (Piñon Nuts)Orchard locations (i.e. low land values, good elevation
provide a significant source of protein - in levels+ rainfall, existing high producing, native Piñon
surpassing even pecans & walnuts - withstands), it stands out that those rural communities
significant amounts of Vitamin A, Riboflavin, thiamin,most in need of any economic stimulation were
and niacin - "they really have no food rival in the nutfound in proximity to those parameters. Thus
world". Also, Piñon trees naturally function as aPiñon Orchards would be of significant value
"great carbon sink" for the planet by removingfrom their establishment & Nut harvesting,
carbon. "Certainly, as consumers find they areespecially in those areas currently deemed unsuitable
unknowingly getting more of their protein from eatingfor traditional agricultural crops. It is hopeful that a
'cloned beef protein'' the thought of adding a wildsmall, rural community 'Brands' itself around an
& natural protein to their diet - like that found inincreasing collection and consumption of Piñon
Piñon Nut's - is appealing to the health &Nuts, i.e....hosting a 'Piñon Nut Festival' theme,
environmentally conscious".piñon nut commodities (candies, menu items,
This project involves 'experimental arid landand their resulting establishment of improved,
agriculture' in the creation of a pine nut treePiñon Orchards. Thus co-location of active
improvement program. Improvement programs ofPiñon cultivation in proximity to rural areas in
nut pine trees might involve four main steps: 1)need of any economic stimulation, may prove to be
Selection of superior trees--(i.e. "plus-trees")--fromone of the most exciting benefits.
natural stands; 2) Grafting of these superiorEconomic Benefits from increased Piñon Nut
plus-trees into orchards to produce geneticallyProduction
improved seed (nuts); 3) Field testing of theseBeneficial affects to a local economy develop from
plus-trees to identify the best trees and improve theseveral different channels: the sale of nuts crops
orchard seed ( cone and nut size) by removingwould impact the economy directly, through the
inferior trees; and 4) Continued improvement andpurchases of goods and services locally, and
development of still-better varieties throughindirectly, as those purchases in turn generate
interbreeding of the best trees. It is known that pinepurchases of intermediate goods and services from
nut crop size is strongly environmentally influenced,other, related sectors of the economy. In addition,
and that pests and health are important. For example,these direct and indirect effects increases
tip moth activity depresses piñon coneemployment and income, enhancing overall economy
production, as does dry weather and high temps,purchasing power, thereby inducing further spending
regardless of the tree's genetics. And tree size, anon goods and services. This cycle continues until the
important determinant of cone crop potential, is veryspending eventually leaks out of the local economy
much influenced by soil type, climate, pest history,as a result of taxes, savings, or purchases of
competition, etc. There are so many factorsnon-locally produced goods and services.
affecting the 'phenotype' -- what you see -- that theBarriers to Commercial Cultivation of the Piñono
only way to determine the characteristics of theComplexities of water use, water rights and water
'genotype' of a tree is to grow offspring from itsavailability in Colorado, and all arid lands of the west.o
seeds in progeny testing.Piñon nut (seed) production is cyclic and good
Arid-zone agriculture as it relates to the Piñoncrops can occur at 2-7 year intervals, but the
Pineaverage crop has been produced at 4.1 yr intervals
"As an area of research and development, arid-zonefrom a 58 year study.o Slow growth rates in typical
agriculture, or desert agriculture, includes studies ofspecimens, unless placed under intense cultivation or
how to increase the agricultural productivity of landsgrafting practices.o Limited existing knowledge of
dominated by lack of freshwater, an abundance ofcross-pollination and nut size and nut yield
heat and sunlight, and usually one or more ofimprovement from either cultivated or native
extreme winter cold, short rainy season, saline soil orPiñon plantations in the United States.o Limited
water, strong dry winds, poor soil structure,existing knowledge or study of grafting success on
over-grazing, limited technological development,piñon or other nut pines species.o Possibly the
poverty..." Wikipedia...most drought hardy characteristics of any nut
Two basic approaches to solutions areo view theproducing plant -increasingly important in a 'global
given environmental and socioeconomic characteristicswarming' climate 'onset'.o Higher protein per weight
as negative obstacles to be overcomeo view asthan all nuts but cashew.o Piñon has adaptability
many as possible of them as positive resources toto the widest range of soil types.o Piñon incurs
be usedlittle damage from 'browsing' by deer, elk, rabbits, and
Vision of the Future - Colorado Piñon Nutrodents over its entire range.o Higher and best use
Orchards?of arid lands than beef cattle raising on an output of
In looking to the future, it is possible to seeprotein per acre. (Piñon nuts = 123% more
increasing numbers of Farmer's & Landownersprotein efficient per acre than beef.)o Few disease
throughout the southwest appraise the benefits ofand insect herbivory concerns.
now managing their own unprofitable arid PiñonThe Nut bearing pines historically have had little
Woodlands as active "Piñon Nut Orchards".scholarly focus as a crop producer. In (1917) Dr.
Developed breeding, pollination & tree cultivationRobert T. Norris (NNGA) recognized the pine nuts
practices - already in use to improve crop yields onpotential (and future) : "I presume that the extensive
Pecan, Walnut, & Apple Orchards can be appliedplanting of pine trees for food purposes will have to
to economic benefit on a Piñon Nut Orchard. "Await until we have advanced to the point of putting
farmer can create either a transplant or seedling seedother kinds of nut trees (walnuts, pecans, etc.) upon
orchard, or enhance the productivity of the nativegood ground first. Pines will be employed for the
Piñon trees already on the land too" said Alanmore barren hillsides when the folks of ... hundred
Peterson who is pioneering the research. And withyears from now begin to complain of the high cost
Piñon nuts selling for over $15 a pound - thisof living".
really does represent a new: "Business Model for the..."No sentiment is more acknowledged in the family
Environment."of Agriculturists than that the few who can afford it
"CULTIVATORS OF THE EARTH ARE THE MOSTshould incur the risk & expense of all
VALUABLE CITIZENS. THEY ARE MOST VIGOROUS,improvements and give the benefit freely to the
THE MOST INDEPENDENT, THE VIRTUOUS, ANDmany of more restricted circumstances.